ETV Bharat / bharat

SC dismisses plea alleging bias in listing of cases, imposes fine on advocate

A bench led by Justice Arun Mishra dismissed a plea filed by lawyer Reepak Kansal alleging that the registry of the top court gives preference to influential lawyers' plea and disrupts ordinary lawyers' plea by finding unnecessary defects in it.

SC
SC
author img

By

Published : Jul 6, 2020, 3:12 PM IST

New Delhi: The Supreme Court dismissed a plea on Monday alleging bias in the listing of cases by its registry officials and imposed a fine of Rs 100 on an advocate for filing such a petition.

The bench comprising Justice Arun Mishra and S A Nazeer said it was dismissing the PIL filed by lawyer Reepal Kansal and was imposing a cost of Rs 100 on him for filing such a petition.

Kansal said that due to technical glitches, the bench couldn't pronounce its judgement via video conference and apprised of its verdict telephonically.

The lawyer said that the court has held that the allegations had no basis. The PIL alleged that preference in the listing of cases are being given to influential lawyers/petitioners.

The plea had also sought a direction to the apex court's Secretary-General and other officials to stop discrimination against not-so-influential lawyers.

The plea said there was no mechanism to address complaints against erring officers of the registry who favour some law firms/advocates for reasons best known to them.

It also sought direction to the officials concerned not to point out unnecessary defects in cases of ordinary advocates/petitioners and refund the excess court fee and other charges.

The apex court, on June 19, had reserved its verdict on the PIL seeking a direction to its registry officials not to give preferences to cases filed by influential advocates or litigants in listing before benches at the challenging times when virtual courts are functioning due to prevailing COVID-19 pandemic.

During the hearing, the top court had expressed unhappiness over the plea saying the apex court's registry has been working "day-and-night" for the benefit of litigants as well as advocates.

ALSO READ: 60,628 cases pending in SC as on June 1; figure closer to pre-lockdown period

New Delhi: The Supreme Court dismissed a plea on Monday alleging bias in the listing of cases by its registry officials and imposed a fine of Rs 100 on an advocate for filing such a petition.

The bench comprising Justice Arun Mishra and S A Nazeer said it was dismissing the PIL filed by lawyer Reepal Kansal and was imposing a cost of Rs 100 on him for filing such a petition.

Kansal said that due to technical glitches, the bench couldn't pronounce its judgement via video conference and apprised of its verdict telephonically.

The lawyer said that the court has held that the allegations had no basis. The PIL alleged that preference in the listing of cases are being given to influential lawyers/petitioners.

The plea had also sought a direction to the apex court's Secretary-General and other officials to stop discrimination against not-so-influential lawyers.

The plea said there was no mechanism to address complaints against erring officers of the registry who favour some law firms/advocates for reasons best known to them.

It also sought direction to the officials concerned not to point out unnecessary defects in cases of ordinary advocates/petitioners and refund the excess court fee and other charges.

The apex court, on June 19, had reserved its verdict on the PIL seeking a direction to its registry officials not to give preferences to cases filed by influential advocates or litigants in listing before benches at the challenging times when virtual courts are functioning due to prevailing COVID-19 pandemic.

During the hearing, the top court had expressed unhappiness over the plea saying the apex court's registry has been working "day-and-night" for the benefit of litigants as well as advocates.

ALSO READ: 60,628 cases pending in SC as on June 1; figure closer to pre-lockdown period

ETV Bharat Logo

Copyright © 2025 Ushodaya Enterprises Pvt. Ltd., All Rights Reserved.