House adjourned for the day
The Rajya Sabha has been adjourned till 9:00 am on February 8 (Monday).
Rajya Sabha adjourned for the day
Rajya Sabha LIVE
14:49 February 05
14:10 February 05
BJP MP Anil Jain
Anil Jain , MP from Uttar Pradesh (BJP) said that the Government's strength is revealed in challenging times. Through DBT , funds were transferred to farmers, he said.
14:08 February 05
Union Minister Ramdas Athawale
Ramdas Athawale addresses
Ramdas Athawale, MoS Social Justice and Empowerment said that for the welfare of SC/ST allocations need to be made. Everyone said that the farm laws are 'black'. He asked why the leaders resorted to such prolonged protest causing trouble to farmers, he said.
14:01 February 05
BJP MP Indu Bala Goswami
'People supports Modi government'
Indu Bala Goswami , MP from Himachal Pradesh (BJP), said that it is hard to count on the achievements Prime Minister Narendra Modi has made in the last six years.
By lighting lamps and ringing bells people support PM , but , Opposition is not fine with it, she said. People have accepted the transparent government , she said
13:44 February 05
Subash Chandra Bose Pilli , MP from Andhra Pradesh (YSCRP) speaks in Telugu on Special category status to Andhra Pradesh and Pollavaram project.
13:38 February 05
BJP MP Neeraj Shekhar
'PM's actions matter, not his beard'
Neeraj Shekar , MP from Uttar Pradesh (BJP) said that Narendra Modi government has done the best work in last years. Emergency was during the Congress when no Congress leaders met Narasimha Rao, he said.
He appealed people to understand that the government works for the welfare of government.
He further stated that many are resorting to personal attack against PM Modi. He asked why people are concerned about his long beard and chappals. One need to look at his actions and assess him. He has uplifted goodwill of the country , he said.
13:37 February 05
BJD MP Sasmit Patra
Samsit Patra , BJD MP responded to Dharmendra Pradhan's comment on BJD statement that Swaminathan report was not implemented.
13:37 February 05
'Weapons are made in human mind'
'Weapons are made in human mind'
K J Alphons , MP from Kerala (BJP) said that even though GDP is negative, government expenditure has increased. Child mortality rate has reduced. Regarding incident on R-Day , it was treason, he said. Weapons are made in human mind, he added.
13:17 February 05
Mallikarjun Kharge addresses
Mallikarjun Kharge , MP from Karnataka (INC) mentioned about Champaran satyagraha and added that over 6 crore farmers have not yet received a rupee from the government.
13:13 February 05
Sardar Balwinder Singh , MP from Punjab addresses
Sardar Balwinder Singh , MP from Punjab (SAD) said that farmers have realised the agenda behind the laws. He responded to Agriculture Minister's question on what is black in farm laws.The Essential Commodities Act is diluted and trade laws are brought in, he said.
13:13 February 05
Akhilesh Prasad Singh , MP from Bihar addresses
Akhilesh Prasad Singh , MP from Bihar (Congress) said that APMC was abolished in Bihar. In states like Punjab and Haryana , average income of farmers is Rs 15,000. He urged the government not to insult the farmers.
12:55 February 05
'What is 'black' in farm laws?'
'What is 'black' in farm laws?'
Tomar said that small farmers are higher in proportion in the country and MSP would not yield them benefits, rather FPOs would. Over 1 lakh crore has been allocated for building infrastructure. FPOs would enable better production and technology, he said.
Slamming Opposition parties, he asked what is black in farm laws. Many MPs raised their voice in support of farmers protest, but , none stated what is wrong with the laws. We convened many meeting with farmers' union and we asked them to point out the follies in the laws, but none pointed out. They are told that their land would be taken away, he added.
False information is spread across the country regarding farm laws. Modi government treats land with water, not blood , like the Congress.
Further, he also stated that in Punjab, as per the law, farmers can be imprisoned if found guilty in any crime committed in contract farming. Whereas, the Centre's laws do not have such provisions, he said.
12:39 February 05
We have started to provide MSP, 50% more than the production cost. Also, Rs 1 lakh crore agriculture infrastructure fund has been given under Aatmanirbhar package. We have tried to ensure the requisite investment reaches the agriculture sector: Agriculture Minister NS Tomar
12:19 February 05
'Rs 2.36 lakh crores allocated to gram panchayats'
15th Finance Commission has recommended for providing Rs 2.36 lakh crores to gram panchayats, which has been accepted by the Cabinet. Around Rs 43,000-cr have been sanctioned for healthcare in rural areas. Rs 2.8 lakh crores will be spent via gram panchayats in 5 yrs: Agri Min
12:17 February 05
Agriculture Minister Narendra Singh Tomar
'2020 was a year of hardship'
Union Minister of Agriculture, Narendra Singh Tomar said that 2020 was a year of hardship for India. The country showed strength in combating Covid pandemic. Now, ventilators are facilitated in every district and we are a global supplier of Covid vaccine. Every section needs upliftement in this Budget, but , emphasis should be on health sector, he added.
11:54 February 05
Agriculture Minister Narendra Singh Tomar addresses Parliament.
11:34 February 05
Article 370 abrogated for devolopment'
'Article 370 abrogated for devolopment'
Samsher Singh Manhas, MP from Jammu and Kashmir said that Artilce 370 resulted in complete integration of the state with the country.
Jammu Kashmir is deprived of large scale industries and the abrogation would lead to devolopment.
11:33 February 05
'K shaped economic recovery, not V shaped'
'K shaped economic recovery, not V shaped'
Anand Sharma , MP from Himachal Pradesh (INC) said that the Indian economy has been witnessing a K shaped recovery , not V shaped.
Constitutionality of the farm laws is questionable. Agriculture is not listed in the concurrent list , he stated.
11:29 February 05
Union Minister for Agriculture, Narendra Singh Tomar reaches Parliament.
11:03 February 05
'Modi government stands for humanity'
'Modi government stands for humanity'
Rakesh Sinha , nominated BJP MP said that people in India are happy with Public Distribution system. He added that if needed Modi government could have reaped huge benefits with the Covid vaccine , but, the government did not resort to business or diplomacy in the crisis , rather stood for humanity
10:55 February 05
Barricades in border similar to Berlin wall
Pratap Singh Bajwa , MP from Punjab (Congress) compared barricades of Ghazipur border with Berlin wall, speaking in Punjabi. It is an opportunity for PM Modi to be a statesman, be a Sardar Patel. Meet the farmers and tell them you will repeal the laws, he said.
10:55 February 05
Vinay P Sahasrabuddhe , MP from Maharastra
Aatmanirbhar Bharat is our vision
Vinay P Sahasrabuddhe , MP from Maharastra (BJP) said that the government strives for the welfare of citizens, not based on populism. PM leads for Aatmanirbhar Bharat, he said.
10:38 February 05
Agriculture , a state subject, says Punjab MP
Sardar Sukhdev Singh Dhindsa , MP from Punjab (SAD) said that during India's freedom movement , Sikhs fought for the country and now they are termed as Khalistanis.
Agriculture is a state subject and now as the Central has passed farm laws, federal system is disrupted.
10:35 February 05
Release Siddhique Kappan , urges Abdul Wahab
Release Siddhique Kappan, urges Abdul Wahab
Abdul Wahab , MP from Kerala (IUML) said that Kerala journalist Siddhique Kappan has been imprisoned for covering Hathras case. Journalists are protesting in Kerala , please release him , he urged.He raised his objection to motion of thanks.
He also stated that in order to reduce vaccine hesitancy , Covid vaccine should be administrated to PM , MPs, MLAs and local leaders. He also raised the demand to reinstate MPLADS funds stating that it has been suspended for two years but the amount of previous year has not yet given.
10:25 February 05
Human rights violation in protest sites
Human rights violation in protest sites
"You (govt) have dug up trenches to suppress farmers' stir. You've not done it for them, but for yourself. You snapped their water and electricity supplies & even removed toilets, without thinking that women are also there. This is a human rights violation." said BSP MP Satish Mishra.
"Nails have been fixed near the protest sites. I think govt would not have made this kind of preparation at Pakistan border as it is doing at Delhi borders. Annadatas are being called the enemy of the nation. I urge you to shun ego & repeal the three laws," he added.
10:23 February 05
BJP issues whip to RS MPs to be present in House from Feb 8-12
Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) has issued a three-line whip to its Rajya Sabha MPs to be present in the House from February 8 to February 12 to support the government's stand as some "very important" business will be taken up for discussion and passing in the House.
"All BJP members in Rajya Sabha are hereby informed that some very important business will be taken up for discussion and passing in the Rajya Sabha from Monday, February 8 to February 12th," said BJP in a statement.
"All Members of BJP in Rajya Sabha are therefore requested to be positively present in the House throughout all five days and support the Government's stand," BJP added.
10:10 February 05
Once patriots, now anti-nationals, says Raut
Once patriots, now anti-nationals
Sanjay Raut , MP from Maharastra (Shiv Sena) said when people in Punjab fought against Mughals, Britishers they were ardent patriots, but ,now when they fight for their own rights they are termed as anti-nationals.
The person who insulted Tricolour should be arrested immediately , but he is wandering free. Contrastingly , over 200 farmers are lodged in Tihar jail.
Kangana Ranaut and Arnab Goswami enjoys lot of freedom. Goswami's Whatsapp messages were leaked and he had confidential information on Pulwama attack which is a grave mistake done to the country.
He added that Shashi Tharor, Manjeed Singh , Dharmendra Singh are termed anti national for voicing their opinion and documenting farmers' protest.
09:50 February 05
Repeal farm laws, urges Parful Patel
Repeal farm laws, urges Parful Patel
Parful Patel , MP from Maharastra (NCP) said that there are glaring disparities in the bill that is passed with the one that was brought in the Parliament. Earlier, it said that any market would be under the auspices of marketing committee, but now it is stated that it is under a private entity. He urged the government to address the farmers demands.
09:28 February 05
Generate jobs for youth, says Binoy Viswam
Generate jobs for youth, says Binoy Viswam
Resuming yesterday's address, Binoy Viswam, MP from Kerala (CPI) said he cannot support the farm laws. He added that the financial expenditure in 2019 was 5.1 % while in 2020 it was 2.7%. He also added that the Government should be keen to address the youngsters' problems. Similar to MNREGA, an employment scheme must be in place, he said
06:31 February 05
House proceedings begin
RS proceedings begin, discussion on motion of thanks to President's address continues
New Delhi: Proceedings of Rajya Sabha began on Friday morning as the House continues the discussion on motion of thanks on the President's address.
"Some of the members exceeded their time yesterday so that time will be reduced from their party's quota. This has to be understood by all," said Rajya Sabha Chairman M Venkaiah Naidu.
Meanwhile, BJP MP Mahesh Poddar has given a short duration discussion notice in Rajya Sabha over 'efficient handling of COVID-19 situation in the country'.
Rajya Sabha meets for five hours daily in accordance with COVID-19 protocols in place. Yesterday in Rajya Sabha, All India Trinamool Congress (TMC) MP Derek O'Brien said that the government failed to uphold Parliament's sanctity because of its arrogance, adding that it has "failed India at many levels".
While, raising the agitating farmers' issue in the Rajya Sabha, AAP leader Sanjay Singh urged the Centre to withdraw the new farm laws, stating that "have mercy on farmers who are being lathi-charged, called traitors, terrorists and Khalistanis".
14:49 February 05
House adjourned for the day
The Rajya Sabha has been adjourned till 9:00 am on February 8 (Monday).
14:10 February 05
BJP MP Anil Jain
Anil Jain , MP from Uttar Pradesh (BJP) said that the Government's strength is revealed in challenging times. Through DBT , funds were transferred to farmers, he said.
14:08 February 05
Union Minister Ramdas Athawale
Ramdas Athawale addresses
Ramdas Athawale, MoS Social Justice and Empowerment said that for the welfare of SC/ST allocations need to be made. Everyone said that the farm laws are 'black'. He asked why the leaders resorted to such prolonged protest causing trouble to farmers, he said.
14:01 February 05
BJP MP Indu Bala Goswami
'People supports Modi government'
Indu Bala Goswami , MP from Himachal Pradesh (BJP), said that it is hard to count on the achievements Prime Minister Narendra Modi has made in the last six years.
By lighting lamps and ringing bells people support PM , but , Opposition is not fine with it, she said. People have accepted the transparent government , she said
13:44 February 05
Subash Chandra Bose Pilli , MP from Andhra Pradesh (YSCRP) speaks in Telugu on Special category status to Andhra Pradesh and Pollavaram project.
13:38 February 05
BJP MP Neeraj Shekhar
'PM's actions matter, not his beard'
Neeraj Shekar , MP from Uttar Pradesh (BJP) said that Narendra Modi government has done the best work in last years. Emergency was during the Congress when no Congress leaders met Narasimha Rao, he said.
He appealed people to understand that the government works for the welfare of government.
He further stated that many are resorting to personal attack against PM Modi. He asked why people are concerned about his long beard and chappals. One need to look at his actions and assess him. He has uplifted goodwill of the country , he said.
13:37 February 05
BJD MP Sasmit Patra
Samsit Patra , BJD MP responded to Dharmendra Pradhan's comment on BJD statement that Swaminathan report was not implemented.
13:37 February 05
'Weapons are made in human mind'
'Weapons are made in human mind'
K J Alphons , MP from Kerala (BJP) said that even though GDP is negative, government expenditure has increased. Child mortality rate has reduced. Regarding incident on R-Day , it was treason, he said. Weapons are made in human mind, he added.
13:17 February 05
Mallikarjun Kharge addresses
Mallikarjun Kharge , MP from Karnataka (INC) mentioned about Champaran satyagraha and added that over 6 crore farmers have not yet received a rupee from the government.
13:13 February 05
Sardar Balwinder Singh , MP from Punjab addresses
Sardar Balwinder Singh , MP from Punjab (SAD) said that farmers have realised the agenda behind the laws. He responded to Agriculture Minister's question on what is black in farm laws.The Essential Commodities Act is diluted and trade laws are brought in, he said.
13:13 February 05
Akhilesh Prasad Singh , MP from Bihar addresses
Akhilesh Prasad Singh , MP from Bihar (Congress) said that APMC was abolished in Bihar. In states like Punjab and Haryana , average income of farmers is Rs 15,000. He urged the government not to insult the farmers.
12:55 February 05
'What is 'black' in farm laws?'
'What is 'black' in farm laws?'
Tomar said that small farmers are higher in proportion in the country and MSP would not yield them benefits, rather FPOs would. Over 1 lakh crore has been allocated for building infrastructure. FPOs would enable better production and technology, he said.
Slamming Opposition parties, he asked what is black in farm laws. Many MPs raised their voice in support of farmers protest, but , none stated what is wrong with the laws. We convened many meeting with farmers' union and we asked them to point out the follies in the laws, but none pointed out. They are told that their land would be taken away, he added.
False information is spread across the country regarding farm laws. Modi government treats land with water, not blood , like the Congress.
Further, he also stated that in Punjab, as per the law, farmers can be imprisoned if found guilty in any crime committed in contract farming. Whereas, the Centre's laws do not have such provisions, he said.
12:39 February 05
We have started to provide MSP, 50% more than the production cost. Also, Rs 1 lakh crore agriculture infrastructure fund has been given under Aatmanirbhar package. We have tried to ensure the requisite investment reaches the agriculture sector: Agriculture Minister NS Tomar
12:19 February 05
'Rs 2.36 lakh crores allocated to gram panchayats'
15th Finance Commission has recommended for providing Rs 2.36 lakh crores to gram panchayats, which has been accepted by the Cabinet. Around Rs 43,000-cr have been sanctioned for healthcare in rural areas. Rs 2.8 lakh crores will be spent via gram panchayats in 5 yrs: Agri Min
12:17 February 05
Agriculture Minister Narendra Singh Tomar
'2020 was a year of hardship'
Union Minister of Agriculture, Narendra Singh Tomar said that 2020 was a year of hardship for India. The country showed strength in combating Covid pandemic. Now, ventilators are facilitated in every district and we are a global supplier of Covid vaccine. Every section needs upliftement in this Budget, but , emphasis should be on health sector, he added.
11:54 February 05
Agriculture Minister Narendra Singh Tomar addresses Parliament.
11:34 February 05
Article 370 abrogated for devolopment'
'Article 370 abrogated for devolopment'
Samsher Singh Manhas, MP from Jammu and Kashmir said that Artilce 370 resulted in complete integration of the state with the country.
Jammu Kashmir is deprived of large scale industries and the abrogation would lead to devolopment.
11:33 February 05
'K shaped economic recovery, not V shaped'
'K shaped economic recovery, not V shaped'
Anand Sharma , MP from Himachal Pradesh (INC) said that the Indian economy has been witnessing a K shaped recovery , not V shaped.
Constitutionality of the farm laws is questionable. Agriculture is not listed in the concurrent list , he stated.
11:29 February 05
Union Minister for Agriculture, Narendra Singh Tomar reaches Parliament.
11:03 February 05
'Modi government stands for humanity'
'Modi government stands for humanity'
Rakesh Sinha , nominated BJP MP said that people in India are happy with Public Distribution system. He added that if needed Modi government could have reaped huge benefits with the Covid vaccine , but, the government did not resort to business or diplomacy in the crisis , rather stood for humanity
10:55 February 05
Barricades in border similar to Berlin wall
Pratap Singh Bajwa , MP from Punjab (Congress) compared barricades of Ghazipur border with Berlin wall, speaking in Punjabi. It is an opportunity for PM Modi to be a statesman, be a Sardar Patel. Meet the farmers and tell them you will repeal the laws, he said.
10:55 February 05
Vinay P Sahasrabuddhe , MP from Maharastra
Aatmanirbhar Bharat is our vision
Vinay P Sahasrabuddhe , MP from Maharastra (BJP) said that the government strives for the welfare of citizens, not based on populism. PM leads for Aatmanirbhar Bharat, he said.
10:38 February 05
Agriculture , a state subject, says Punjab MP
Sardar Sukhdev Singh Dhindsa , MP from Punjab (SAD) said that during India's freedom movement , Sikhs fought for the country and now they are termed as Khalistanis.
Agriculture is a state subject and now as the Central has passed farm laws, federal system is disrupted.
10:35 February 05
Release Siddhique Kappan , urges Abdul Wahab
Release Siddhique Kappan, urges Abdul Wahab
Abdul Wahab , MP from Kerala (IUML) said that Kerala journalist Siddhique Kappan has been imprisoned for covering Hathras case. Journalists are protesting in Kerala , please release him , he urged.He raised his objection to motion of thanks.
He also stated that in order to reduce vaccine hesitancy , Covid vaccine should be administrated to PM , MPs, MLAs and local leaders. He also raised the demand to reinstate MPLADS funds stating that it has been suspended for two years but the amount of previous year has not yet given.
10:25 February 05
Human rights violation in protest sites
Human rights violation in protest sites
"You (govt) have dug up trenches to suppress farmers' stir. You've not done it for them, but for yourself. You snapped their water and electricity supplies & even removed toilets, without thinking that women are also there. This is a human rights violation." said BSP MP Satish Mishra.
"Nails have been fixed near the protest sites. I think govt would not have made this kind of preparation at Pakistan border as it is doing at Delhi borders. Annadatas are being called the enemy of the nation. I urge you to shun ego & repeal the three laws," he added.
10:23 February 05
BJP issues whip to RS MPs to be present in House from Feb 8-12
Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) has issued a three-line whip to its Rajya Sabha MPs to be present in the House from February 8 to February 12 to support the government's stand as some "very important" business will be taken up for discussion and passing in the House.
"All BJP members in Rajya Sabha are hereby informed that some very important business will be taken up for discussion and passing in the Rajya Sabha from Monday, February 8 to February 12th," said BJP in a statement.
"All Members of BJP in Rajya Sabha are therefore requested to be positively present in the House throughout all five days and support the Government's stand," BJP added.
10:10 February 05
Once patriots, now anti-nationals, says Raut
Once patriots, now anti-nationals
Sanjay Raut , MP from Maharastra (Shiv Sena) said when people in Punjab fought against Mughals, Britishers they were ardent patriots, but ,now when they fight for their own rights they are termed as anti-nationals.
The person who insulted Tricolour should be arrested immediately , but he is wandering free. Contrastingly , over 200 farmers are lodged in Tihar jail.
Kangana Ranaut and Arnab Goswami enjoys lot of freedom. Goswami's Whatsapp messages were leaked and he had confidential information on Pulwama attack which is a grave mistake done to the country.
He added that Shashi Tharor, Manjeed Singh , Dharmendra Singh are termed anti national for voicing their opinion and documenting farmers' protest.
09:50 February 05
Repeal farm laws, urges Parful Patel
Repeal farm laws, urges Parful Patel
Parful Patel , MP from Maharastra (NCP) said that there are glaring disparities in the bill that is passed with the one that was brought in the Parliament. Earlier, it said that any market would be under the auspices of marketing committee, but now it is stated that it is under a private entity. He urged the government to address the farmers demands.
09:28 February 05
Generate jobs for youth, says Binoy Viswam
Generate jobs for youth, says Binoy Viswam
Resuming yesterday's address, Binoy Viswam, MP from Kerala (CPI) said he cannot support the farm laws. He added that the financial expenditure in 2019 was 5.1 % while in 2020 it was 2.7%. He also added that the Government should be keen to address the youngsters' problems. Similar to MNREGA, an employment scheme must be in place, he said
06:31 February 05
House proceedings begin
RS proceedings begin, discussion on motion of thanks to President's address continues
New Delhi: Proceedings of Rajya Sabha began on Friday morning as the House continues the discussion on motion of thanks on the President's address.
"Some of the members exceeded their time yesterday so that time will be reduced from their party's quota. This has to be understood by all," said Rajya Sabha Chairman M Venkaiah Naidu.
Meanwhile, BJP MP Mahesh Poddar has given a short duration discussion notice in Rajya Sabha over 'efficient handling of COVID-19 situation in the country'.
Rajya Sabha meets for five hours daily in accordance with COVID-19 protocols in place. Yesterday in Rajya Sabha, All India Trinamool Congress (TMC) MP Derek O'Brien said that the government failed to uphold Parliament's sanctity because of its arrogance, adding that it has "failed India at many levels".
While, raising the agitating farmers' issue in the Rajya Sabha, AAP leader Sanjay Singh urged the Centre to withdraw the new farm laws, stating that "have mercy on farmers who are being lathi-charged, called traitors, terrorists and Khalistanis".
Last Updated : Feb 5, 2021, 3:08 PM IST
