ETV Bharat / bharat

Fear of coup prevented CDS appointment earlier: Ex-Army chief

Former Army chief General (retd) Shankar Roy Chowdhury on Wednesday said the military is always subordinate to the civil authorities in the country, but an 'unsubstantiated' fear of a coup if the forces were brought under one head had prevented the then political establishment from taking a decision on it.

Former Army chief
Former Army chief
author img

By

Published : Jan 8, 2020, 7:48 PM IST

Kolkata: Terming the appointment of a Chief of Defence Staff (CDS) as a welcome move, former Army chief General (retd) Shankar Roy Chowdhury on Wednesday said it had not been done earlier owing to the then political bosses' fear of a coup.

He said the appointment of a CDS was due for a long time and the services wanted it to be there in the country so that the Army, Navy and Air Force come under one umbrella, 'but the problem was political.'

"The fear of a coup was ingrained among the earlier political bosses if all the three forces - Army, Navy and Air Force - were brought under one umbrella and that was the only reason that a post of CDS was not created," Roy Chowdhury told newspersons here.

General Bipin Rawat, who retired as the Army chief on December 31, has taken charge as India's first Chief of Defence Staff the next day with a mandate to bring in convergence in the functioning of the Army, Navy and the Indian Air Force and bolster the country's military prowess.

Gen (retd) Roy Chowdhury said the military is always subordinate to the civil authorities in the country, but an 'unsubstantiated' fear of a coup if the forces were brought under one head had prevented the then political establishment from taking a decision on it.

"This is the single reason why the country did not have a CDS so far," the former Army chief said. He said the post of CDS is important for the coordination of the three forces.

The former Army officer said the CDS will always have to work under internal pressure to meet with demands from the Army, Navy and the Air Force with each trying to get more of the defence budget pie in order to meet their requirements. "The CDS will have to make his judgement on the requirements of the three forces and judiciously recommend distribution of funds to each," Roy Chowdhury said.

The former Army chief said all the three services are under-funded and the demand for at least two per cent of the country's GDP to be spent on the Defence budget has never been met. "The CDS has to ensure that the resources are allocated equitably or priority wise within the services, in his recommendations to the government," he said.

Also, read: Proposal to create Air Defence Command should be prepared by June 30, says Gen Rawat

Kolkata: Terming the appointment of a Chief of Defence Staff (CDS) as a welcome move, former Army chief General (retd) Shankar Roy Chowdhury on Wednesday said it had not been done earlier owing to the then political bosses' fear of a coup.

He said the appointment of a CDS was due for a long time and the services wanted it to be there in the country so that the Army, Navy and Air Force come under one umbrella, 'but the problem was political.'

"The fear of a coup was ingrained among the earlier political bosses if all the three forces - Army, Navy and Air Force - were brought under one umbrella and that was the only reason that a post of CDS was not created," Roy Chowdhury told newspersons here.

General Bipin Rawat, who retired as the Army chief on December 31, has taken charge as India's first Chief of Defence Staff the next day with a mandate to bring in convergence in the functioning of the Army, Navy and the Indian Air Force and bolster the country's military prowess.

Gen (retd) Roy Chowdhury said the military is always subordinate to the civil authorities in the country, but an 'unsubstantiated' fear of a coup if the forces were brought under one head had prevented the then political establishment from taking a decision on it.

"This is the single reason why the country did not have a CDS so far," the former Army chief said. He said the post of CDS is important for the coordination of the three forces.

The former Army officer said the CDS will always have to work under internal pressure to meet with demands from the Army, Navy and the Air Force with each trying to get more of the defence budget pie in order to meet their requirements. "The CDS will have to make his judgement on the requirements of the three forces and judiciously recommend distribution of funds to each," Roy Chowdhury said.

The former Army chief said all the three services are under-funded and the demand for at least two per cent of the country's GDP to be spent on the Defence budget has never been met. "The CDS has to ensure that the resources are allocated equitably or priority wise within the services, in his recommendations to the government," he said.

Also, read: Proposal to create Air Defence Command should be prepared by June 30, says Gen Rawat

ZCZC
PRI GEN NAT
.KOLKATA CAL27
DEF-CDS-ROYCHOWDHURY
Fear of coup prevented CDS appointment earlier: ex-Army chief
         Kolkata, Jan 8 (PTI) Terming the appointment of
a Chief of Defence Staff (CDS) as a welcome move, former Army
chief General (retd) Shankar Roy Chowdhury on Wednesday said
it had not been done earlier owing to the then political
bosses' fear of a coup.
         He said the appointment of a CDS was due for a long
time and the services wanted it to be there in the country so
that the Army, Navy and Air Force come under one umbrella,
"but the problem was political."
         "The fear of a coup was ingrained among the earlier
political bosses if all the three forces - Army, Navy and Air
Force - were brought under one umbrella and that was the only
reason that a post of CDS was not created," Roy Chowdhury told
newspersons here.
         General Bipin Rawat, who retired as the Army chief on
December 31, has taken charge as India's first Chief of
Defence Staff the next day with a mandate to bring in
convergence in the functioning of the Army, Navy and the
Indian Air Force and bolster the country's military prowess.
         Gen (retd) Roy Chowdhury said the military is always
subordinate to the civil authorities in the country, but an
"unsubstantiated" fear of a coup if the forces were brought
under one head had prevented the then political establishment
from taking a decision on it.
         "This is the single reason why the country did not
have a CDS so far," the former Army chief said.
         He said the post of CDS is important for the
coordination of the three forces.
         The former Army officer said the CDS will always have
to work under internal pressure to meet with demands from the
Army, Navy and the Air Force with each trying to get more of
the defence budget pie in order to meet their requirements.
         "The CDS will have to make his judgement on the
requirements of the three forces and judiciously recommend
distribution of funds to each," Roy Chowdhury said.
         The former Army chief said all the three services are
under-funded and the demand for at least two per cent of the
country's GDP to be spent on the Defence budget has never been
met.
         "The CDS has to ensure that the resources are
allocated equitably or priority wise within the services, in
his recommendations to the government," he said. PTI AMR
NN
NN
01081641
NNNN
ETV Bharat Logo

Copyright © 2025 Ushodaya Enterprises Pvt. Ltd., All Rights Reserved.