ETV Bharat / bharat

Death penalty for rapists no solution to deep-rooted problem: Gargi Chakravartty

Speaking to ETV Bharat, women's rights activist and vice president of National Federation of Indian Women Gargi Chakravartty said that the demands calling for the death penalty for rape accused are "not a solution" to a problem which is much more deep-rooted. She stressed on "police reforms" and "judicial efficiency" as plausible solutions to curb the menace.

Death penalty for rapists no solution to deep-rooted problem: Gargi Chakravartty
Death penalty for rapists no solution to deep-rooted problem: Gargi Chakravartty
author img

By

Published : Dec 3, 2019, 10:13 PM IST

New Delhi: With demands for the death penalty for rape accused echoing from all corners of society, including the lawmakers, following the brutal gangrape and murder of a veterinary doctor in Hyderabad, women's rights activist Gargi Chakravartty said that the problem is "deep-rooted" and "lynching or execution is not a solution".

Death penalty for rapists no solution to deep-rooted problem: Gargi Chakravartty

"Demands for lynching and execution for rape accused, by the public and some of the MP's in Parliament, does not provide a solution to the problem. Two things are needed at the moment - police reforms and fast track courts, more district courts and judicial efficiency, " said Chakravartty while speaking to ETV Bharat.

"It is necessary to gender sensitise the police," added Chakravartty.

Terming the tendency to unleash sexual assault as a "disease", the vice president of National Federation of Indian Women (NFIW) said, "If the doctor is unable to diagnose the disease it is difficult to treat the disease. We have to really ponder and pressurise the government to do something about it."

Criticising the induction of "criminals " as lawmakers of the country, Chakravartty said, "Criminals are there in the Parliament as well, and unfortunately there is a nexus between the criminals and the politicians. You can have a look at the cases of rape reported from Unnao, Kathua and that of Chinmayanand, and the way the accused were acquitted."

"We need to look at the acquittal reports, who are the people helping them to get acquitted. That is the most fundamental question which will expose a lot of things happening around us, " added the activist.

Elaborating on how patriarchy works as a major trigger towards the perpetration of crime against women and attacking the right-wing ideology for encouraging the same, Chakravartty said,"It is a deep-rooted malaise, and the root cause is the patriarchal mindset, and this mindset is now nurtured and encouraged by the ideology of the right-wing, which thinks that Manusmriti is the basis of family structure and society, which encourages subjugation of women."

She further said, "Children growing up observe the way their father behaves with their mother, the way their sisters are being treated. All this discrimination against women is also an invisible form of violence."

Also read: Charred body of woman found in Bihar, rape suspected

"One case is followed by another, and now there is an upsurge in such crimes, " added Chakravartty.

Swift death penalty, public lynching and castration of rape convicts were among the demands made by members in both houses of Parliament on Monday as they expressed deep outrage over the rape and murder of a veterinarian in Hyderabad and other such incidents in the country, while the Centre said it was ready to amend laws to bring in stringent provisions and ensure speedy justice.

Also read: 'Silent, Strong and swift': Indian Navy release teaser ahead of Navy day

Rajya Sabha Chairman M Venkaiah Naidu even suggested a rethink on allowing convicts in heinous crimes to go in for mercy appeals.

New Delhi: With demands for the death penalty for rape accused echoing from all corners of society, including the lawmakers, following the brutal gangrape and murder of a veterinary doctor in Hyderabad, women's rights activist Gargi Chakravartty said that the problem is "deep-rooted" and "lynching or execution is not a solution".

Death penalty for rapists no solution to deep-rooted problem: Gargi Chakravartty

"Demands for lynching and execution for rape accused, by the public and some of the MP's in Parliament, does not provide a solution to the problem. Two things are needed at the moment - police reforms and fast track courts, more district courts and judicial efficiency, " said Chakravartty while speaking to ETV Bharat.

"It is necessary to gender sensitise the police," added Chakravartty.

Terming the tendency to unleash sexual assault as a "disease", the vice president of National Federation of Indian Women (NFIW) said, "If the doctor is unable to diagnose the disease it is difficult to treat the disease. We have to really ponder and pressurise the government to do something about it."

Criticising the induction of "criminals " as lawmakers of the country, Chakravartty said, "Criminals are there in the Parliament as well, and unfortunately there is a nexus between the criminals and the politicians. You can have a look at the cases of rape reported from Unnao, Kathua and that of Chinmayanand, and the way the accused were acquitted."

"We need to look at the acquittal reports, who are the people helping them to get acquitted. That is the most fundamental question which will expose a lot of things happening around us, " added the activist.

Elaborating on how patriarchy works as a major trigger towards the perpetration of crime against women and attacking the right-wing ideology for encouraging the same, Chakravartty said,"It is a deep-rooted malaise, and the root cause is the patriarchal mindset, and this mindset is now nurtured and encouraged by the ideology of the right-wing, which thinks that Manusmriti is the basis of family structure and society, which encourages subjugation of women."

She further said, "Children growing up observe the way their father behaves with their mother, the way their sisters are being treated. All this discrimination against women is also an invisible form of violence."

Also read: Charred body of woman found in Bihar, rape suspected

"One case is followed by another, and now there is an upsurge in such crimes, " added Chakravartty.

Swift death penalty, public lynching and castration of rape convicts were among the demands made by members in both houses of Parliament on Monday as they expressed deep outrage over the rape and murder of a veterinarian in Hyderabad and other such incidents in the country, while the Centre said it was ready to amend laws to bring in stringent provisions and ensure speedy justice.

Also read: 'Silent, Strong and swift': Indian Navy release teaser ahead of Navy day

Rajya Sabha Chairman M Venkaiah Naidu even suggested a rethink on allowing convicts in heinous crimes to go in for mercy appeals.

Intro:New Delhi: As the lawmakers from both Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha raising a huge and cry over the increasing incidents of heinous crime against women, renowned woman acvitist and vice president of National Federation of Indian Women (NFIW) Gargi Chakravartty on Tuesday expressed serious concern over the nexus between criminal and parliamentarians.



Body:"The on going crime against women is a systematic problem. It's like a cancer, if the doctor is unable to find the disease...It's problematic," said Chakravartty.

Expressing her concern, Chakravartty said, "not only the criminals are in the Parliament, their nexus is really a serious threat."

She said that Unnao, Kathua as well as Chinmayanand incidents are glaring examples where lawmakers are involved.

"Acquittal of the accused is also a serious matter. We need to ponder who are the people involved in their acquittal," said the woman activist.

As per Association of Democratic Reforms (ADR) survey, nearly half of the newly elected Lok Sabha members have criminal charges against them, a 26 percent increase as compared to 2014.

Out of the 539 elected candidates analysed by ADR, as many as 233 MPs or 43 percent have criminal charges.

BJP has 116 MPs or 39 percent of its wining candidates with criminal cases, followed by 29 MPs (57 percent) from the Congress, 13 (81 percent) from JDU, 10 (43 percent) from the DMK and nine (41 percent) from the TMC.

Ironically, 29 percent of the cases registered against the sitting MPs involves around rape, murder, attempt to murder or crime against women.

"Public lynching is not the solution. What we need is police reforms and fast track trial of such cases," said Chakravartty.

She was against public lynching of the accused. "Public lynching is not the aputuin..." said the NFIA vice president.

She was referring to a statement made by Rajya Sabha MP Jaya Bacchan in the Parliament.



Conclusion:The brutal gang rape and murder of Hyderabad based veterinarian has raised another fresh debate over the safety and security of women across India.

It was in 2012, when brutal gang rape of a 23 year old woman raised a huge national outrage.

end.
ETV Bharat Logo

Copyright © 2025 Ushodaya Enterprises Pvt. Ltd., All Rights Reserved.