ETV Bharat / bharat

Banning 27 pesticides will handover market worth crores to China : CCFI

author img

By

Published : Jun 24, 2020, 7:05 PM IST

The Crop Care Federation of India, an agro-chemical industry body has alleged that central government's move to ban the usage of 27 commonly-used pesticides, weedicides and fungicides, will defeat the very purpose of Prime Minister Narendra Modi's call for Make In India. However, the industry is not happy with the move and intends to register its strong objection with the government.

Banning 27 pesticides will handover market worth crores to China : CCFI
Banning 27 pesticides will handover market worth crores to China : CCFI

New Delhi: The central government's move to ban the usage of 27 commonly-used pesticides, weedicides and fungicides, for being harmful to humans and animals have met with stiff protest from farmers and pesticide manufacturers. The move will defeat the very purpose of Prime Minister Narendra Modi's call for Make In India, Crop Care Federation of India (CCFI), an agro-chemical industry body has alleged.


"All the 27 molecules have been approved by Indian government, meeting all scientific evaluations for safety and efficacy. Today, Indian companies have both resources and skilled man-power to produce the pesticides and now the government is banning them," Harish Mehta, Senior Advisor, the CCFI told ETV Bharat.On May 14, the Ministry of Agriculture had issued a draft notification, intending to ban the chemicals. In the notification, the ministry had given all stakeholders time till 27 June to submit their objections and suggestions.

"The banned pesticides are widely used by farmers for the past 40-50 years and if the chemicals are banned, then they will be forced to import it from countries like China, Japan and USA. Thereby, giving a market worth Rs 13,000 crore to our Chinese competitors alone," he added.

However, the industry is not happy with the move and intends to register its strong objection with the government.

According to CCFI, there is a total domestic market of pesticides worth Rs 6000 in India. The move will not only stop the manufacturing of the chemicals but also bring export earnings of the Indian industry worth Rs 7000 crore to a standstill.

Moreover, these pesticides account for 40 percent of the domestic market and the alternative available to the farmers will be branded, readymade and expensive ones produced by the multinational companies (MNCs).

Recently, while addressing an virtual conference, Agriculture Minister Narendra Singh Tomar said that the exports of the chemicals will not be banned and announced that the time for inviting comments from pesticides manufacturers and other bodies, has been extended from 45 days to 90 days. But the industry expressed grave dissatisfaction over the recent development too.

A week after writing a letter to the agricultural ministry and Central Insecticides Board & Registration Committee (CIBRC), CCFI wrote another letter asking on what grounds the ban was initiated, for which the body has not received any response yet.

Mehta demanded that if the ban is not on scientific grounds than the government should withdraw it.

He alleged that the issue was highlighted in such way so that it brings bad name to Indian companies and subsequently, pave way for MNCs into the Indian market.

"We have extracted data from 2015 to 2019, in which samples of fruits, vegetables, wheat etc. were tested. And what we found was that only in 1126 out 53,000 samples, traces of chemicals were found. And it is totally safe for consumption," he told ETV Bharat, on being asked whether presence of pesticides in food items is one of the reasons to ban them.

The percentage of chemicals in samples was less than two percent, as prescribed by the government of India, he said, adding that in such a situation banning the pesticides on the grounds that it has adverse effect on human body is totally baseless.

Many manufacturers believe that Anupam Verma Committee report, which reviewed the generic pesticides is arbitrary, and has not taken into the record all the evidence and data on hand about the pesticides.

Therefore, the industry has demanded to appoint a high-powered scientific committee to look into the Anupam Varma Committee’s report.

Meanwhile, Indian agrochemical companies and farmers have demanded the government to withdraw the decision.

CCFI also demanded that tax on ready made pesticides imported from foreign countries should be increased to 25% so that profit and import is lessened. Thereby, giving a wide market to Indian companies.

Also read: Yogi Adityanath all set to announce jobs for one crore people in UP

New Delhi: The central government's move to ban the usage of 27 commonly-used pesticides, weedicides and fungicides, for being harmful to humans and animals have met with stiff protest from farmers and pesticide manufacturers. The move will defeat the very purpose of Prime Minister Narendra Modi's call for Make In India, Crop Care Federation of India (CCFI), an agro-chemical industry body has alleged.


"All the 27 molecules have been approved by Indian government, meeting all scientific evaluations for safety and efficacy. Today, Indian companies have both resources and skilled man-power to produce the pesticides and now the government is banning them," Harish Mehta, Senior Advisor, the CCFI told ETV Bharat.On May 14, the Ministry of Agriculture had issued a draft notification, intending to ban the chemicals. In the notification, the ministry had given all stakeholders time till 27 June to submit their objections and suggestions.

"The banned pesticides are widely used by farmers for the past 40-50 years and if the chemicals are banned, then they will be forced to import it from countries like China, Japan and USA. Thereby, giving a market worth Rs 13,000 crore to our Chinese competitors alone," he added.

However, the industry is not happy with the move and intends to register its strong objection with the government.

According to CCFI, there is a total domestic market of pesticides worth Rs 6000 in India. The move will not only stop the manufacturing of the chemicals but also bring export earnings of the Indian industry worth Rs 7000 crore to a standstill.

Moreover, these pesticides account for 40 percent of the domestic market and the alternative available to the farmers will be branded, readymade and expensive ones produced by the multinational companies (MNCs).

Recently, while addressing an virtual conference, Agriculture Minister Narendra Singh Tomar said that the exports of the chemicals will not be banned and announced that the time for inviting comments from pesticides manufacturers and other bodies, has been extended from 45 days to 90 days. But the industry expressed grave dissatisfaction over the recent development too.

A week after writing a letter to the agricultural ministry and Central Insecticides Board & Registration Committee (CIBRC), CCFI wrote another letter asking on what grounds the ban was initiated, for which the body has not received any response yet.

Mehta demanded that if the ban is not on scientific grounds than the government should withdraw it.

He alleged that the issue was highlighted in such way so that it brings bad name to Indian companies and subsequently, pave way for MNCs into the Indian market.

"We have extracted data from 2015 to 2019, in which samples of fruits, vegetables, wheat etc. were tested. And what we found was that only in 1126 out 53,000 samples, traces of chemicals were found. And it is totally safe for consumption," he told ETV Bharat, on being asked whether presence of pesticides in food items is one of the reasons to ban them.

The percentage of chemicals in samples was less than two percent, as prescribed by the government of India, he said, adding that in such a situation banning the pesticides on the grounds that it has adverse effect on human body is totally baseless.

Many manufacturers believe that Anupam Verma Committee report, which reviewed the generic pesticides is arbitrary, and has not taken into the record all the evidence and data on hand about the pesticides.

Therefore, the industry has demanded to appoint a high-powered scientific committee to look into the Anupam Varma Committee’s report.

Meanwhile, Indian agrochemical companies and farmers have demanded the government to withdraw the decision.

CCFI also demanded that tax on ready made pesticides imported from foreign countries should be increased to 25% so that profit and import is lessened. Thereby, giving a wide market to Indian companies.

Also read: Yogi Adityanath all set to announce jobs for one crore people in UP

ETV Bharat Logo

Copyright © 2024 Ushodaya Enterprises Pvt. Ltd., All Rights Reserved.