ETV Bharat / bharat

How different is Chandrayaan-2 from Chandrayaan-1?

author img

By

Published : Jul 13, 2019, 5:26 PM IST

Updated : Jul 15, 2019, 9:46 AM IST

Chandrayaan -1, India's first mission to the moon made the breakthrough discovery of detecting the presence of water molecules on the lunar surface, With the Chandrayaan - 2, India aims to take a step further and become only the fourth nation to achieve a 'soft landing' on the moon.

Thumb

New Delhi: India's second sojourn to the moon, Chandrayaan 2 is an Indian lunar mission that will boldly go where no country has ever gone before -- the Moon's south polar region.

Scientists ready the Vikram lander
Scientists ready the Vikram lander

So, how different is the Chandrayaan -2 from its predecessor?

The Budget

While the Chandrayaan - 1 mission cost India only an estimated Rs 386 crore, the upgraded Chandrayaan -2 mission will cost Rs 978 crore, including Rs 603 crore for the orbiter, lander, rover, navigation and ground support network and Rs 375 crore for the rocket. A fact which shows the cost-effectiveness of the missions is that the Hollywood space blockbuster Interstellar cost a whopping Rs 1,062 crore ($165 million).

The launchers

While Chandrayaan-1 was launched by the Polar Satellite Launch Vehicle (PSLV-C11), the Chandrayaan-2 will be launched by the GSLV Mk-III.

View of GSLV MkIII-M1 vehicle at the Second Launch Pad
View of GSLV MkIII-M1 vehicle at the Second Launch Pad
Payload

Chandrayaan-1 had 11 payloads --five from India, three from Europe, two from the US and one from Bulgaria.

On the other hand, Chandrayaan -2 will carry 13 Indian payloads (8 on orbiter, 3 on lander and 2 on rover) and one passive experiment from NASA.

The landing

After orbiting the moon for a few days, Chandrayaan -1's Moon Impact Probe (MIP) crash-landed on the lunar surface on 14 November 2008, near a crater at the south pole. During its free-fall, it detected the presence of water on the moon.

However, with Chandrayaan -2, the lander would 'soft land' on the moon at a predetermined site and deploy the Rover. India would become the fourth country after USA, Russia, and China to perform a soft landing on the moon and put a rover on it.

Fully integrated Chandrayaan-1 spacecraft (left) and loading it to Thermovac Chamber (right)
Fully integrated Chandrayaan-1 spacecraft (left) and loading it to Thermovac Chamber (right)

The Goal

Chandrayaan-1 orbited the moon and ejected a probe that discovered water molecules in craters at the moon’s poles, with the highest density inside permanently shadowed craters at the South Pole. The presence of water was deemed a breakthrough discovery.

The mission further detected traces of magnesium and silicon on the moon.

Pragyan Rover mounted on the ramp projecting from out of the sides of Vikram lander
Pragyan Rover mounted on the ramp projecting from out of the sides of Vikram lander

With Chandrayaan - 2, India will continue its search for water on the lunar surface. As part of the mission, Chandrayaan - 2 will land near the South pole of the moon - an unexplored territory as it is permanently under the shadow region.

The aim is to analyze crust samples for signs of water and helium-3. That isotope is limited on Earth, but is abundant on the moon. It could potentially solve the earth's power woes as it can theoretically meet global energy demands for 250 years if effectively used.

How successful was Chandrayaan -1?

After making 3400 orbits of the Moon, equipment failure forced the Chandrayaan -1 mission to be abandoned. Although the mission was less than 10 months in duration, and less than half the intended two years in length, ISRO termed the mission successful, as it had completed 95% of its primary objectives.

Dr. Anand, Chief scientific Officer of Jahawarlal Nehru Planetarium speaks to ETV Bharat and illustrates Chandrayan 2
Chandrayaan - 2: Ashok Chakra, Tricolour, and ISRO Logo

Chnadrayaan -2 is set to leave a lasting imprint of India's presence on the moon. The Rover has an Ashoka Chakra on one wheel, and the ISRO logo on the other, while the Lander will have a small tricolour too, and these will be engraved on the surface of the moon.

Read: Chandrayaan -2 is a very important, prestigious mission: ISRO chairman

New Delhi: India's second sojourn to the moon, Chandrayaan 2 is an Indian lunar mission that will boldly go where no country has ever gone before -- the Moon's south polar region.

Scientists ready the Vikram lander
Scientists ready the Vikram lander

So, how different is the Chandrayaan -2 from its predecessor?

The Budget

While the Chandrayaan - 1 mission cost India only an estimated Rs 386 crore, the upgraded Chandrayaan -2 mission will cost Rs 978 crore, including Rs 603 crore for the orbiter, lander, rover, navigation and ground support network and Rs 375 crore for the rocket. A fact which shows the cost-effectiveness of the missions is that the Hollywood space blockbuster Interstellar cost a whopping Rs 1,062 crore ($165 million).

The launchers

While Chandrayaan-1 was launched by the Polar Satellite Launch Vehicle (PSLV-C11), the Chandrayaan-2 will be launched by the GSLV Mk-III.

View of GSLV MkIII-M1 vehicle at the Second Launch Pad
View of GSLV MkIII-M1 vehicle at the Second Launch Pad
Payload

Chandrayaan-1 had 11 payloads --five from India, three from Europe, two from the US and one from Bulgaria.

On the other hand, Chandrayaan -2 will carry 13 Indian payloads (8 on orbiter, 3 on lander and 2 on rover) and one passive experiment from NASA.

The landing

After orbiting the moon for a few days, Chandrayaan -1's Moon Impact Probe (MIP) crash-landed on the lunar surface on 14 November 2008, near a crater at the south pole. During its free-fall, it detected the presence of water on the moon.

However, with Chandrayaan -2, the lander would 'soft land' on the moon at a predetermined site and deploy the Rover. India would become the fourth country after USA, Russia, and China to perform a soft landing on the moon and put a rover on it.

Fully integrated Chandrayaan-1 spacecraft (left) and loading it to Thermovac Chamber (right)
Fully integrated Chandrayaan-1 spacecraft (left) and loading it to Thermovac Chamber (right)

The Goal

Chandrayaan-1 orbited the moon and ejected a probe that discovered water molecules in craters at the moon’s poles, with the highest density inside permanently shadowed craters at the South Pole. The presence of water was deemed a breakthrough discovery.

The mission further detected traces of magnesium and silicon on the moon.

Pragyan Rover mounted on the ramp projecting from out of the sides of Vikram lander
Pragyan Rover mounted on the ramp projecting from out of the sides of Vikram lander

With Chandrayaan - 2, India will continue its search for water on the lunar surface. As part of the mission, Chandrayaan - 2 will land near the South pole of the moon - an unexplored territory as it is permanently under the shadow region.

The aim is to analyze crust samples for signs of water and helium-3. That isotope is limited on Earth, but is abundant on the moon. It could potentially solve the earth's power woes as it can theoretically meet global energy demands for 250 years if effectively used.

How successful was Chandrayaan -1?

After making 3400 orbits of the Moon, equipment failure forced the Chandrayaan -1 mission to be abandoned. Although the mission was less than 10 months in duration, and less than half the intended two years in length, ISRO termed the mission successful, as it had completed 95% of its primary objectives.

Dr. Anand, Chief scientific Officer of Jahawarlal Nehru Planetarium speaks to ETV Bharat and illustrates Chandrayan 2
Chandrayaan - 2: Ashok Chakra, Tricolour, and ISRO Logo

Chnadrayaan -2 is set to leave a lasting imprint of India's presence on the moon. The Rover has an Ashoka Chakra on one wheel, and the ISRO logo on the other, while the Lander will have a small tricolour too, and these will be engraved on the surface of the moon.

Read: Chandrayaan -2 is a very important, prestigious mission: ISRO chairman

ZCZC
PRI GEN NAT
.BENGALURU MDS2
KA-MLAS-LD TALKS
Karnataka: Cong MLA Nagaraj hints at reconsidering resignation
(Eds: Updates with MLA's quotes, fresh developments)
         Bengaluru, Jul 13 (PTI) As the Congress intensified efforts to woo back its disgruntled MLAs in Karnataka on Saturday, one of them hinted that he might consider withdrawing his resignation and also said he would try to persuade others.
         State Housing Minister and Hoskote MLA MTB Nagaraj, one of the 16 rebel Congress-JD(S) MLAs who resigned from the Assembly last week, dealing a blow to the coalition government, said senior Congress leaders, including former chief minister Siddaramiah, met him and asked him to withdraw his resignation.
         "Siddaramaiah and Dinesh Gundu Rao called me and requested me to withdraw the resignation and stay in the party. I have sought time to mull over it.
         "I told them I will speak to Chikkaballapura MLA Sudhakar and persuade him to withdraw his resignation. We are planning to stay here only," Nagaraj told reporters.
         He was flanked by Deputy Chief Minister G Parameshwara, state Water Resource Minister D K Shivakumar and other Congress leaders.
         To a query on whether all the differences were sorted out, Nagaraj said he had resigned due to certain "discontentment" and that there was disagreement in every political party.
         "The party high-command is trying to persuade the MLAs. I will also try my best to help them in their efforts," he added.
         Nagaraj then left for state Congress Legislature Party (CLP) leader Siddaramaiah's residence.
         A day after Chief Minister H D Kumaraswamy made a surprise announcement in the Assembly that he would seek a trust vote in the House, efforts were intensified by the ruling coalition to reach out to the rebel MLAs.
         Congress's "troubleshooter" Shivakumar reached Nagaraj's residence early Saturday morning and camped there for almost four-and-a-half hours, trying to pacify the Hoskote MLA.
         Subsequently, Parameshwara too reached Nagaraj's house to convince him to withdraw his resignation.
         A similar attempt was on to persuade MLAs Ramalinga Reddy, Munirathna, K Sudhakar and R Roshan Baig.
         Sources in the Janata Dal (Secular) said Kumaraswamy was in direct talks with at least four Congress legislators, who had resigned, and was hopeful that they would withdraw their resignations.
         Triggering speculation, a group of Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) leaders, led by MLA S R Vishwanath and Bengaluru corporator Padmanabha Reddy, met Ramalinga Reddy at his residence.
         However, Ramalinga Reddy refused to comment on the development, saying he would not speak on politics till July 15 as he had to appear before the Assembly speaker.
         Meanwhile, his daughter and Congress MLA Sowmya Reddy said she had no information about the meeting.
         "I am in the Congress and I have not resigned. My father has resigned and all the questions pertaining to his resignation should be asked to him," she said.
         In a bid to keep their flocks together ahead of the floor test in the Assembly that is likely to take place in the coming week, both the Congress and the BJP have shifted their MLAs to hotels and resorts.
         Earlier, commenting on the developments, state BJP president B S Yeddyurappa said these efforts would not yield any result as the fall of the coalition government was "imminent".
         "There is confusion in the Congress and the JD(S) due to which the MLAs are fleeing these parties. A systematic conspiracy is going on to bring the MLAs back," the former Karnataka chief minister told reporters here.
         "The atmosphere is chaotic and the fall of the government is imminent," he said.
         Claiming that the ruling coalition had lost majority in the Assembly, Yeddyurappa said seeking a vote of confidence was "meaningless".
         Kumaraswamy made the announcement about seeking a trust vote on the floor of the Assembly after the Supreme Court ordered the speaker on Friday to maintain status quo on the resignations of 10 rebel MLAs of the Congress and the JD(S) till July 16.
         The coalition government, which has been shaky since its formation last year following a post-poll arrangement in the wake of a hung verdict, is facing a serious crisis now with 16 legislators -- 13 of the Congress and three of the JD(S) -- resigning from the Assembly.
         Besides, two Independent MLAs, who were made ministers recently to provide stability to the government, have quit the cabinet and withdrawn their support to the government.
         The ruling coalition's strength in the House is 116 (Congress 78, JD(S) 37 and BSP one), besides the speaker.
         With the support of the two independents, the opposition BJP has 107 MLAs in the 224-member House.
         If the resignations of the 16 MLAs are accepted, the ruling coalition's tally will be reduced to 100.
         The speaker has a vote too. PTI GMS KSU ROH
RC
07131536
NNNN
Last Updated : Jul 15, 2019, 9:46 AM IST
ETV Bharat Logo

Copyright © 2024 Ushodaya Enterprises Pvt. Ltd., All Rights Reserved.