ETV Bharat / state

Maradu flats demolition: SC directs removal of debris, seeks report

The Apex Court has ordered the Kerala government to restore the area around Maradu flats and clear the debris leftover from its demolition. The court has also sought a report in this matter. The illegally constructed Maradu flats were demolished on Sunday.

SC asks Kerala Gov to remove debris and restore area around Maradu flats
SC asks Kerala Gov to remove debris and restore area around Maradu flats
author img

By

Published : Jan 13, 2020, 5:40 PM IST

Updated : Jan 13, 2020, 7:46 PM IST

New Delhi: The Supreme Court Monday directed the Kerala government to remove the debris, including from backwaters, of four apartment complexes in Kochi's Maradu area that were demolished on the apex court's order for being built in violation of the coastal regulation zone (CRZ) norms.

"It is a painful job, a painful duty," said a bench, comprising Justices Arun Mishra and M R Shah, after it was informed by the state government that the top court's order has been complied with and the buildings demolished.

"We will not dispose of this (petition) now. You will have to remove the debris. There are reports that some portion of debris has fallen in backwaters. You have to restore the area," the bench told the state's counsel.

One of the advocates representing some of the Maradu flat owners said that the apex court has ordered a "fine balance" and has given interim compensation of Rs 25 lakh to each of them.

The lawyer said the top court has also granted liberty to flat owners to approach the civil court to initiate appropriate proceedings against the builder.

When the lawyer said that nothing was happening against the officials who had permitted the illegality, the bench said, "Something is happening in this. Let us wait for that".

The counsel said there were some flat owners who had more the one flat in the demolished buildings but the one-member committee, which was set up pursuant to the order of the apex court to oversee demolition and assess total compensation payable to affected buyers, has said that compensation would be paid for one flat only.

"You file a proper application about this," the bench said.

Regarding other issues, including setting up of one court to deal with pleas filed by buyers to initiate appropriate proceedings against the builder, the court asked them to file proper applications.

The bench asked the state government to file report before it with regard to removal of debris of the demolished buildings and posted the matter for hearing on February 10.

On May 8, 2019 the apex court had directed that these buildings be removed within a month as they were constructed in a notified CRZ, which was part of the tidally-influenced water body in Kerala.

It had passed the order after taking note of a report of a committee, which had stated that when the buildings were built, the area was already notified as a CRZ and construction was prohibited.

It had on September 27 directed demolition of these flats within 138 days, a timeline given by the Kerala government, and had asked the state to pay Rs 25 lakh interim compensation to each flat owner within four weeks.

The top court had on September 30 last year refused to entertain a plea of flat owners seeking a stay on its order to demolish the apartment complexes.

The counsel appearing for Kerala had earlier told the apex court that in compliance of its earlier order, the state had paid Rs 27.99 crore as interim compensation to the Maradu flat owners and it will be paying Rs 33.51 crore more to them.

Read:| Koalas could be endangered due to bushfires: Minister

New Delhi: The Supreme Court Monday directed the Kerala government to remove the debris, including from backwaters, of four apartment complexes in Kochi's Maradu area that were demolished on the apex court's order for being built in violation of the coastal regulation zone (CRZ) norms.

"It is a painful job, a painful duty," said a bench, comprising Justices Arun Mishra and M R Shah, after it was informed by the state government that the top court's order has been complied with and the buildings demolished.

"We will not dispose of this (petition) now. You will have to remove the debris. There are reports that some portion of debris has fallen in backwaters. You have to restore the area," the bench told the state's counsel.

One of the advocates representing some of the Maradu flat owners said that the apex court has ordered a "fine balance" and has given interim compensation of Rs 25 lakh to each of them.

The lawyer said the top court has also granted liberty to flat owners to approach the civil court to initiate appropriate proceedings against the builder.

When the lawyer said that nothing was happening against the officials who had permitted the illegality, the bench said, "Something is happening in this. Let us wait for that".

The counsel said there were some flat owners who had more the one flat in the demolished buildings but the one-member committee, which was set up pursuant to the order of the apex court to oversee demolition and assess total compensation payable to affected buyers, has said that compensation would be paid for one flat only.

"You file a proper application about this," the bench said.

Regarding other issues, including setting up of one court to deal with pleas filed by buyers to initiate appropriate proceedings against the builder, the court asked them to file proper applications.

The bench asked the state government to file report before it with regard to removal of debris of the demolished buildings and posted the matter for hearing on February 10.

On May 8, 2019 the apex court had directed that these buildings be removed within a month as they were constructed in a notified CRZ, which was part of the tidally-influenced water body in Kerala.

It had passed the order after taking note of a report of a committee, which had stated that when the buildings were built, the area was already notified as a CRZ and construction was prohibited.

It had on September 27 directed demolition of these flats within 138 days, a timeline given by the Kerala government, and had asked the state to pay Rs 25 lakh interim compensation to each flat owner within four weeks.

The top court had on September 30 last year refused to entertain a plea of flat owners seeking a stay on its order to demolish the apartment complexes.

The counsel appearing for Kerala had earlier told the apex court that in compliance of its earlier order, the state had paid Rs 27.99 crore as interim compensation to the Maradu flat owners and it will be paying Rs 33.51 crore more to them.

Read:| Koalas could be endangered due to bushfires: Minister

Intro:The Supreme Court today took on record the compliance report filed by the state of Kerela on demolition of Maradu flats as per the apex court's earlier order. Though Justice Arun Mishra refused to dispose off the case now and has asked the state to remove the debris and restore the place and submit the report on it by 10th February when the next hearing will take place.


Body:The bench comprising of Justice Arun Mishra and Justice MR Shah have also asked the parties to the case to make an application of their requests and then argue the case. Today some flat owners told the bench that they wanted to approach the HC for the sum of money and wanted the state to take care of the court fees.

Last year the apex court had ordered the demolition of the Maradu flats as they violated the Coastal Regulation Zone rule. They were also asked by the court to pay a compensation of 25 lakhs to the flat owners.


Conclusion:Yesterday the last illegal settlement was also demolished.
Last Updated : Jan 13, 2020, 7:46 PM IST
ETV Bharat Logo

Copyright © 2024 Ushodaya Enterprises Pvt. Ltd., All Rights Reserved.