ETV Bharat / state

Parliament Winter Session Day 8: Amit Shah slams Nehru, Rajya Sabha passes two J&K bills; both houses adjourned

author img

By ETV Bharat English Team

Published : Dec 11, 2023, 9:40 AM IST

Updated : Dec 11, 2023, 8:40 PM IST

Apart from that house is expected to see the laying of reports of the Standing Committee on Water Resources, and 'Demands for Grants (2023-24)' of the Ministry of Jal Shakti - Department of Water Resources, River Development and Ganga Rejuvenation will be made by Guman Singh Damor.

Parliament winter session Day 8: Amit Shah to table 2 J-K Bills in Rajya Sabha today
Parliament winter session Day 8: Amit Shah to table 2 J-K Bills in Rajya Sabha today

New Delhi: Rajya Sabha on Monday passed the Jammu and Kashmir Reservation (Amendment) Bill, 2023, and Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation (Amendment) Bill, 2023 the bills through a voice vote after the opposition walked out of the Upper house. The bills were passed in the Lok Sabha on December 6.

"I have already promised statehood of Jammu and Kashmir will be restored at the appropriate time. Article 370 in J-K gave rise to separatism which in turn promoted terrorism. The Supreme Court verdict on J-K is a big defeat of opposition parties", Amit Shah said in Rajya Sabha.

Amit Shah said that the Jammu and Kashmir Constitution does not hold any validity after the Supreme Court's verdict on Article 370 abrogation. Those who say Article 370 is 'permanent' are insulting the Constitution and Constituent Assembly, HM Amit Shah said in Rajya Sabha.

The winter session of Parliament began on December 4 and will culminate on December 22.

Here are the updates for the day:

  • 8.20 pm Rajya Sabha proceedings will resume on Tuesday, December 12 at 11 am.
  • 8.15 pm The Jammu and Kashmir Reservation (Amendment) Bill,2023, and Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation (Amendment)Bill, 2023have been passed unanimously.
  • 8.12 pm Two crore tourists visited Kashmir post Article 370 abrogation, 100 film shoots have taken place, and three theatres opened, says Shah in RS
  • 8.10 pm Opposition walks out of Rajya Sabha during Amit Shah's reply on the Jammu and Kashmir Reservation (Amendment) Bill.
  • 8.07 pm Amit Shah in Rajya Sabha says, now India has one Constitution, one flag and one prime minister.
  • 8.05 pm We entered their home to take revenge for terror incidents in Uri, Pulwama, Shah says in Rajya Sabha.
  • 8.00 pm During the Rajya Sabha session, Amit Shah says we have tried to finish the ecosystem of terror funding.
  • 7.56 pm PM Modi, myself, Cabinet and BJP will not run away from owning responsibility for abrogating Article 370 in J-K. Kashmiri people reject those who talk of separatism, says Shah.
  • 7.54 pm Had there been no untimely ceasefire in Kashmir, there would have been no PoK, says Amit Shah.
  • 7.52 pm Amit Shah praises the efforts of Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government and says that they have improved the lives of locals.
  • 7.50 pm Union Minister Amit Shah attacks Nehru, says J-K accession to India delayed as one person was given this task.
  • 7.38 pm Pakistan-occupied-Kashmir (PoK) belongs to India, nobody can snatch it, Amit Shah says.
  • 7.34 pm Gujarat and Rajasthan have borders with Pakistan as well. There are more Muslims in Gujarat, Uttar Pradesh and Assam as compared to Kashmir. There are not the reasons behind separatism, Article 370 is, Shah says.
  • 7.31 pm "I have already promised statehood of Jammu and Kashmir will be restored at the appropriate time. Article 370 in J-K gave rise to separatism which in turn promoted terrorism. The Supreme Court verdict on J-K is a big defeat of opposition parties", Amit Shah says in Rajya Sabha.
  • 7.27 pm Amit Shah says the Jammu and Kashmir Constitution does not hold any validity after the Supreme Court's verdict on Article 370 abrogation.
  • 7.20 pm Those who say Article 370 is 'permanent' are insulting the Constitution and Constituent Assembly, HM Amit Shah says in Rajya Sabha
  • 7.13 pm Home Minister Amit Shah continues his speech on two Jammu and Kashmir bills in the Rajya Sabha.
  • 7.10 pm BJP MP Sushil Kumar Modi says Congress is against Other Backward Classes.
  • 6.54 pm CPI(M) MP Sivadasan says the Government is controlling the media.
  • 6.44 pm CPI(M) MP John Brittas asks what was the need for removing Jammu and Kashmir's Statehood in 2019.
  • 6.01 pm Lok Sabha will resume on Tuesday, December 12 at 11 am.
  • 5.52 pm BJP MP Sikander Kumar supported the bills and urged the members to support it as well.
  • 5.48 pm SS MP Priyanka Chaturvedi asks Home Minister Amit Shah when will the elections will be conducted in Jammu and Kashmir.
  • 5.38 pm BJP MP Krishan Lal Panwar voices his support for the bills.
  • 5.30 pm BJP MP Sumer Singh Solanki says these bills will bring growth and development to the people of Kashmir.
  • 5.20 pm CPI MP Sandosh Kumar P. opposed the bills.
  • 4.55 pm During the Rajya Sabha session, NCP MP Fauzia Khan says militancy is that cancer that is eating away the beauty of Kashmir.
  • 4.40 pm Congress MP Rajani Ashokrao Patil says it's because of Pandit Nehru that Jammu and Kashmir is part of India.
  • 4.03 pm INC MP, Syed Nasir Hussain objects to Reddy's remark and alleges that he has not read Nehru and Patel about this matter. He says it is because of Nehru that Kashmir is a part of India.
  • 3.53 pm YSRCP MP V. Vijayasai Reddy rises to support both the Bills and express the support of the party and Jagan Mohan Reddy. He says he will highlight a few blunders of Congress government. He says Article 370 is a blunder as well as not taking back Kashmir during the Second war with Pakistan.
  • 3.49 pm Congress' leader in Lok Sabha Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury on Monday asked the government when it would reclaim Pakistan-occupied Kashmir, while also demanding that elections be held in Jammu and Kashmir and its statehood restored.
  • 3.45 pm AAP MP Sanjay Arora appeals Home Minister urging equal consideration for the Punjabi people, particularly the Sikhs who face hardship similar to Hindu Pandits.
  • 3.31 pm DMK leader Tiruchi Siva clarifies in the House says DMK doesn't need to be given other colours, we want to achieve any right of the States within the framework of the Indian Constitution.
  • 3.25 pm DMK leader Tiruchi Siva in Rajya Sabha expresses that an ordinary statement has been hyped. Siva says that the Chair highlighted that the remark about Article 370 was against the order of the Supreme Court. What if Article 370 is reinstituted? Union Minister Amit Shah asks if he is expressing the view of his party or the INDIA grouping.
  • 3.16 pm INC MP Jairam Ramesh says they do not support the quote of Periyar used by the DMK members.
  • 3.11 pm Home Minister Amit Shah asks does Congress support the statement of DMK MP Mohammed Abdulla.
  • 3.08 pm DMK MP Mohammed Abdulla quotes Periyar to say each race has the right to self-determination. Vice-President Jagdeep Dhankar objects strongly to his words, calling it unconstitutional. Leader of Opposition, Mallikarjun Kharge asks the Chair to listen to every member and says the Home Minister is there to rebut and reply to the speeches of all the members.
  • 3.03 pm Union Civil Aviation Minister Jyotiraditya Scindia on Monday announced that nine more airports would be constructed in Uttar Pradesh over the next two years. Replying to supplementaries during the Question Hour in the Rajya Sabha, Scindia said Prime Minister Narendra Modi-led government is giving a huge importance to the civil aviation sector. He said that only 74 airports were constructed in the first 65 years of independence, while 75 airports have been developed in the last nine years of the Modi government, taking the total number to 149. The total includes airports, heliports and waterdromes.
  • 2.49 pm Leader of the house, Piyush Goyal questions the figures pertaining to lack of electricity, power cuts, tourism and unemployment mentioned by AITC MP Nadimul Haque in his speech.
  • 2.15 pm
    BJP MP Sudhanshu Trivedi says the government has taken punitive action against those, who were involved in the Kashmiri Pandits' genocide. He says the BJP government at the Centre has brought about a total transformation of Jammu and Kashmir. He talks about a slew of developmental projects in the J&K. He lauds the government for taking some bold and decisive steps to restore the confidence of Kashmiris.
  • 2.10 pm
    Congress MP Vivek Tankha quotes Vajpayee's words of appreciation for Jawaharlal Nehru.
  • 2 pm
    Rajya Sabha resumes. Discussion is on the Jammu and Kashmir Reservation (Amendment) Bill, 2023 and the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation (Amendment) Bill.
  • 1 pm
    Rajya Sabha to meet at 2 pm
  • 112.45 pm
    BJP MP Laxmikant Vajpayee wants to know if the Civil Aviation Ministry is considering flying 72-seat ATR from Meerut.
  • 12.34 pm
    TMC MP Jawhar Sircar says Hardeep Puri told him that oil marketing companies PS sector are in recovery mode. "How much profit went to private companies,?" Sircar asked Puri.
  • 12.24 pm
    In reply to Congress MP JB Mather Hisham, Hardeep Singh Puri says VAT was reduced in several states.
  • 12.15 pm
    BJD MP Sulata Deb wants to know if the government will offer more benefits to the middle class and women under the Ujjwala scheme.
  • 12.02 pm
    BJP MP Sushil Kumar Modi wants to know how many people were benefited due to PM Ujjawal Yojana
  • 11.43 am
    NCP MP Fauziya Khan proposes setting up a research centre around the site of a project to build an advanced gravitational-wave detector in Maharashtra's Hingoli.
  • 11.46 am
    AAP MP Ashok Kumar Mittal raises of cross-border trafficking, child marriage, and forced prostitution. He demands stringent laws to curb such crimes
  • 11.43 am
    BJP MP Sushil Kumar Modi says like ministers and MPs declare assets, judges also do the same. He demands a proper mechanism to ensure that judges declare assets annually.
  • 11.25 am
    TMC MP Shantanu Sen objects to the National Medical Commission's logo and demands the restoration of the previous logo.
  • 11.25 am
    AIADMK MP Thambidurai demands a road project for Karur.
  • 11.15 am
    CPM MP V Sivadasan pitches for Kannur airport's international status.
  • 11 am
    Rajya Sabha resumes
  • 10.16 am
    The House will also feature statements of Union Ministers on the status of the implementation of various reports and several private members move for leave to introduce Bills.
  • 9.40 am
    Congress MP Manickam Tagore gives Adjournment motion notice in Lok Sabha on a purported viral video showing BJP MLA and former Union Minister Narendra Singh Tomar's son discussing the transfer of bribe money from a businessman.
  • 9.20 am
    Minister of State V Muraleedharan to give statement correcting Meenakshi Lekhi's reply on ‘declaration of Hamas as a terrorist organization’.

New Delhi: Rajya Sabha on Monday passed the Jammu and Kashmir Reservation (Amendment) Bill, 2023, and Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation (Amendment) Bill, 2023 the bills through a voice vote after the opposition walked out of the Upper house. The bills were passed in the Lok Sabha on December 6.

"I have already promised statehood of Jammu and Kashmir will be restored at the appropriate time. Article 370 in J-K gave rise to separatism which in turn promoted terrorism. The Supreme Court verdict on J-K is a big defeat of opposition parties", Amit Shah said in Rajya Sabha.

Amit Shah said that the Jammu and Kashmir Constitution does not hold any validity after the Supreme Court's verdict on Article 370 abrogation. Those who say Article 370 is 'permanent' are insulting the Constitution and Constituent Assembly, HM Amit Shah said in Rajya Sabha.

The winter session of Parliament began on December 4 and will culminate on December 22.

Here are the updates for the day:

  • 8.20 pm Rajya Sabha proceedings will resume on Tuesday, December 12 at 11 am.
  • 8.15 pm The Jammu and Kashmir Reservation (Amendment) Bill,2023, and Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation (Amendment)Bill, 2023have been passed unanimously.
  • 8.12 pm Two crore tourists visited Kashmir post Article 370 abrogation, 100 film shoots have taken place, and three theatres opened, says Shah in RS
  • 8.10 pm Opposition walks out of Rajya Sabha during Amit Shah's reply on the Jammu and Kashmir Reservation (Amendment) Bill.
  • 8.07 pm Amit Shah in Rajya Sabha says, now India has one Constitution, one flag and one prime minister.
  • 8.05 pm We entered their home to take revenge for terror incidents in Uri, Pulwama, Shah says in Rajya Sabha.
  • 8.00 pm During the Rajya Sabha session, Amit Shah says we have tried to finish the ecosystem of terror funding.
  • 7.56 pm PM Modi, myself, Cabinet and BJP will not run away from owning responsibility for abrogating Article 370 in J-K. Kashmiri people reject those who talk of separatism, says Shah.
  • 7.54 pm Had there been no untimely ceasefire in Kashmir, there would have been no PoK, says Amit Shah.
  • 7.52 pm Amit Shah praises the efforts of Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government and says that they have improved the lives of locals.
  • 7.50 pm Union Minister Amit Shah attacks Nehru, says J-K accession to India delayed as one person was given this task.
  • 7.38 pm Pakistan-occupied-Kashmir (PoK) belongs to India, nobody can snatch it, Amit Shah says.
  • 7.34 pm Gujarat and Rajasthan have borders with Pakistan as well. There are more Muslims in Gujarat, Uttar Pradesh and Assam as compared to Kashmir. There are not the reasons behind separatism, Article 370 is, Shah says.
  • 7.31 pm "I have already promised statehood of Jammu and Kashmir will be restored at the appropriate time. Article 370 in J-K gave rise to separatism which in turn promoted terrorism. The Supreme Court verdict on J-K is a big defeat of opposition parties", Amit Shah says in Rajya Sabha.
  • 7.27 pm Amit Shah says the Jammu and Kashmir Constitution does not hold any validity after the Supreme Court's verdict on Article 370 abrogation.
  • 7.20 pm Those who say Article 370 is 'permanent' are insulting the Constitution and Constituent Assembly, HM Amit Shah says in Rajya Sabha
  • 7.13 pm Home Minister Amit Shah continues his speech on two Jammu and Kashmir bills in the Rajya Sabha.
  • 7.10 pm BJP MP Sushil Kumar Modi says Congress is against Other Backward Classes.
  • 6.54 pm CPI(M) MP Sivadasan says the Government is controlling the media.
  • 6.44 pm CPI(M) MP John Brittas asks what was the need for removing Jammu and Kashmir's Statehood in 2019.
  • 6.01 pm Lok Sabha will resume on Tuesday, December 12 at 11 am.
  • 5.52 pm BJP MP Sikander Kumar supported the bills and urged the members to support it as well.
  • 5.48 pm SS MP Priyanka Chaturvedi asks Home Minister Amit Shah when will the elections will be conducted in Jammu and Kashmir.
  • 5.38 pm BJP MP Krishan Lal Panwar voices his support for the bills.
  • 5.30 pm BJP MP Sumer Singh Solanki says these bills will bring growth and development to the people of Kashmir.
  • 5.20 pm CPI MP Sandosh Kumar P. opposed the bills.
  • 4.55 pm During the Rajya Sabha session, NCP MP Fauzia Khan says militancy is that cancer that is eating away the beauty of Kashmir.
  • 4.40 pm Congress MP Rajani Ashokrao Patil says it's because of Pandit Nehru that Jammu and Kashmir is part of India.
  • 4.03 pm INC MP, Syed Nasir Hussain objects to Reddy's remark and alleges that he has not read Nehru and Patel about this matter. He says it is because of Nehru that Kashmir is a part of India.
  • 3.53 pm YSRCP MP V. Vijayasai Reddy rises to support both the Bills and express the support of the party and Jagan Mohan Reddy. He says he will highlight a few blunders of Congress government. He says Article 370 is a blunder as well as not taking back Kashmir during the Second war with Pakistan.
  • 3.49 pm Congress' leader in Lok Sabha Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury on Monday asked the government when it would reclaim Pakistan-occupied Kashmir, while also demanding that elections be held in Jammu and Kashmir and its statehood restored.
  • 3.45 pm AAP MP Sanjay Arora appeals Home Minister urging equal consideration for the Punjabi people, particularly the Sikhs who face hardship similar to Hindu Pandits.
  • 3.31 pm DMK leader Tiruchi Siva clarifies in the House says DMK doesn't need to be given other colours, we want to achieve any right of the States within the framework of the Indian Constitution.
  • 3.25 pm DMK leader Tiruchi Siva in Rajya Sabha expresses that an ordinary statement has been hyped. Siva says that the Chair highlighted that the remark about Article 370 was against the order of the Supreme Court. What if Article 370 is reinstituted? Union Minister Amit Shah asks if he is expressing the view of his party or the INDIA grouping.
  • 3.16 pm INC MP Jairam Ramesh says they do not support the quote of Periyar used by the DMK members.
  • 3.11 pm Home Minister Amit Shah asks does Congress support the statement of DMK MP Mohammed Abdulla.
  • 3.08 pm DMK MP Mohammed Abdulla quotes Periyar to say each race has the right to self-determination. Vice-President Jagdeep Dhankar objects strongly to his words, calling it unconstitutional. Leader of Opposition, Mallikarjun Kharge asks the Chair to listen to every member and says the Home Minister is there to rebut and reply to the speeches of all the members.
  • 3.03 pm Union Civil Aviation Minister Jyotiraditya Scindia on Monday announced that nine more airports would be constructed in Uttar Pradesh over the next two years. Replying to supplementaries during the Question Hour in the Rajya Sabha, Scindia said Prime Minister Narendra Modi-led government is giving a huge importance to the civil aviation sector. He said that only 74 airports were constructed in the first 65 years of independence, while 75 airports have been developed in the last nine years of the Modi government, taking the total number to 149. The total includes airports, heliports and waterdromes.
  • 2.49 pm Leader of the house, Piyush Goyal questions the figures pertaining to lack of electricity, power cuts, tourism and unemployment mentioned by AITC MP Nadimul Haque in his speech.
  • 2.15 pm
    BJP MP Sudhanshu Trivedi says the government has taken punitive action against those, who were involved in the Kashmiri Pandits' genocide. He says the BJP government at the Centre has brought about a total transformation of Jammu and Kashmir. He talks about a slew of developmental projects in the J&K. He lauds the government for taking some bold and decisive steps to restore the confidence of Kashmiris.
  • 2.10 pm
    Congress MP Vivek Tankha quotes Vajpayee's words of appreciation for Jawaharlal Nehru.
  • 2 pm
    Rajya Sabha resumes. Discussion is on the Jammu and Kashmir Reservation (Amendment) Bill, 2023 and the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation (Amendment) Bill.
  • 1 pm
    Rajya Sabha to meet at 2 pm
  • 112.45 pm
    BJP MP Laxmikant Vajpayee wants to know if the Civil Aviation Ministry is considering flying 72-seat ATR from Meerut.
  • 12.34 pm
    TMC MP Jawhar Sircar says Hardeep Puri told him that oil marketing companies PS sector are in recovery mode. "How much profit went to private companies,?" Sircar asked Puri.
  • 12.24 pm
    In reply to Congress MP JB Mather Hisham, Hardeep Singh Puri says VAT was reduced in several states.
  • 12.15 pm
    BJD MP Sulata Deb wants to know if the government will offer more benefits to the middle class and women under the Ujjwala scheme.
  • 12.02 pm
    BJP MP Sushil Kumar Modi wants to know how many people were benefited due to PM Ujjawal Yojana
  • 11.43 am
    NCP MP Fauziya Khan proposes setting up a research centre around the site of a project to build an advanced gravitational-wave detector in Maharashtra's Hingoli.
  • 11.46 am
    AAP MP Ashok Kumar Mittal raises of cross-border trafficking, child marriage, and forced prostitution. He demands stringent laws to curb such crimes
  • 11.43 am
    BJP MP Sushil Kumar Modi says like ministers and MPs declare assets, judges also do the same. He demands a proper mechanism to ensure that judges declare assets annually.
  • 11.25 am
    TMC MP Shantanu Sen objects to the National Medical Commission's logo and demands the restoration of the previous logo.
  • 11.25 am
    AIADMK MP Thambidurai demands a road project for Karur.
  • 11.15 am
    CPM MP V Sivadasan pitches for Kannur airport's international status.
  • 11 am
    Rajya Sabha resumes
  • 10.16 am
    The House will also feature statements of Union Ministers on the status of the implementation of various reports and several private members move for leave to introduce Bills.
  • 9.40 am
    Congress MP Manickam Tagore gives Adjournment motion notice in Lok Sabha on a purported viral video showing BJP MLA and former Union Minister Narendra Singh Tomar's son discussing the transfer of bribe money from a businessman.
  • 9.20 am
    Minister of State V Muraleedharan to give statement correcting Meenakshi Lekhi's reply on ‘declaration of Hamas as a terrorist organization’.
Last Updated : Dec 11, 2023, 8:40 PM IST

For All Latest Updates

ETV Bharat Logo

Copyright © 2024 Ushodaya Enterprises Pvt. Ltd., All Rights Reserved.