ETV Bharat / elections-2019

Economist Kunal Saraogi raises questions on NYAY scheme

Demolishing Congress president Rahul Gandhi's claim of NYAY scheme being a step towards eradication of poverty, economist Kunal Saraogi said that the implementation would be a question. Saraogi also predicted inflation and fiscal deficit

Kunal Saraogi
author img

By

Published : Apr 7, 2019, 3:28 PM IST

Updated : May 8, 2020, 5:30 PM IST

New Delhi: With the announcement of the NYAY scheme ahead of the 2019 general elections, the Congress' ace card to woo voters has been seen as a game changer. However, contradicting the opinion noted economist and financial expert Kunal Saraogi said that the implementation would be a big question.

Speaking to ETV Bharat, Saraogi said, "As of now this scheme seems more of optics than anything else. There are a lot of specifications that need to be decided and the implementation of such a scheme would always be hard".

He added: "If you look at any of the welfare schemes all around the world, you realise that someone is bearing the burden for that and it is always the taxpayers."

Kunal Saraogi

Speculating the after effects, Saraogi said, "If such an ambitious welfare scheme is actually implemented, the burden is going to fall on the taxpayers. This sort of scheme is definitely going to increase the fiscal deficit and inflation can also be expected to rise."

Elaborating on Congress' idea of Goods and Services Tax (GST) 2.0, the expert said that GST has steadily started showing the positives hidden in it and is being systematically rationalised.

He further claimed that the idea of GST 2.0 is the idea of 'one nation, one tax'.

Also Read: I may be arrested in a day or two: Andhra CM

New Delhi: With the announcement of the NYAY scheme ahead of the 2019 general elections, the Congress' ace card to woo voters has been seen as a game changer. However, contradicting the opinion noted economist and financial expert Kunal Saraogi said that the implementation would be a big question.

Speaking to ETV Bharat, Saraogi said, "As of now this scheme seems more of optics than anything else. There are a lot of specifications that need to be decided and the implementation of such a scheme would always be hard".

He added: "If you look at any of the welfare schemes all around the world, you realise that someone is bearing the burden for that and it is always the taxpayers."

Kunal Saraogi

Speculating the after effects, Saraogi said, "If such an ambitious welfare scheme is actually implemented, the burden is going to fall on the taxpayers. This sort of scheme is definitely going to increase the fiscal deficit and inflation can also be expected to rise."

Elaborating on Congress' idea of Goods and Services Tax (GST) 2.0, the expert said that GST has steadily started showing the positives hidden in it and is being systematically rationalised.

He further claimed that the idea of GST 2.0 is the idea of 'one nation, one tax'.

Also Read: I may be arrested in a day or two: Andhra CM

NYAY SEEMS OPTICS, IT IS NOT A WELL LAID PLAN - FINANCIAL EXPERT
The NYAY scheme announced by Rahul Gandhi which is supposed to be Congress's minimum income scheme will be their biggest poll strategy in the run up to the 2019 elections.
To analyse the scheme further, ETV Bharat spoke to financial expert and noted economist Kunal Saraogi. Speaking on the scheme, Saraogi said " as of now this scheme seems more of optics than anything else. There are a lot of specifications that need to be decided and the implementation of such as scheme would always be hard".
Rebuffing the claims of former finance minister P Chidambaram who said that this scheme would not have its burden fall on the middle class, Saraogi said, " if you look at any of the welfare schemes all around the world, you realise that someone is bearing the burden for that and it is always the taxpayers. So most definitely if Sachin ambitious welfare scheme is actually implemented the burden is going to fall on the taxpayers. This sort of scheme is definitely going to increase the fiscal deficit and the inflation can also be expected to rise because of it as a lot of money is being put into a lot of hands".
"The plan as of now it seems is not very well laid. There will be many problems that they will have to face, many technical problems, many legal problems and the biggest hurdle they have in front of them to win the election first" he added.
Speaking on on Congress idea of GST 2.0, the financial expert said "Yes, GST is now beginning to show it's benefits and obviously there was a need to rationalize it and it is being systematically rationalized. The idea in the end is to bring it to one nation one tax and I think even that is what Congress was talking about in its idea of GST 2.0".
Last Updated : May 8, 2020, 5:30 PM IST
ETV Bharat Logo

Copyright © 2025 Ushodaya Enterprises Pvt. Ltd., All Rights Reserved.