Security situation not suitable for 4g services in Jammu & Kashmir: MHA to SC

The Centre has informed the Supreme Court that the special committee constituted to look into the issue of restoring 4G internet in Jammu and Kashmir decided against resuming the services. The Home Ministry's affidavit has come in response to an allegation of contempt of court the petitioner.

New Delhi: The Union Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) has informed the Supreme Court that the special committee constituted for reviewing the situation in Jammu & Kashmir to decide upon relaxing internet restrictions, has met twice since its formation in May and after "wide ranging assessment" it has decided to not relax internet restrictions, including 4G.

The Home Ministry's affidavit has come in response to allegation of contempt of court by the petitioner, Foundation for Media Professionals, which said that despite the top court's order of forming a committee, the government has not done so, there are no notifications on the constitution.

On 11th May, the court had ordered constituting a special committee comprising of 3 officials headed by Home secretary and directed it to examine the petitioner's contentions on non provision of 4G in the UT and consider the alternatives suggested by them which included restricted internet only in certain volatile areas.

Denying contempt of court, the government has informed the court that they had their first meeting on 15th May and there after on 10th June.

"A thorough and comprehensive consideration of all facets of the matter, including the feasibility of the alternatives suggested by the petitioners as well as the recent occurance of terrorism, related incidents in the region, was carried out,"read the affidavit.

The committee is scheduled to meet after 2 months again, however situation will be reviewed regulary by other competent authorities and "if there is an improvement in the security situation appropriate action would accordingly be taken".

The report on the situation has been submitted to Jammu & Kashmir government.

On July 16, a bench headed by Justice N V Ramana directed the Jammu and Kashmir administration and the Centre to respond on the allegations of contempt raised against it in a petition by the Foundation of Media Professionals.

The petitoner moved the Apex court seeking action against officials for allegedly defying the Top court's order on the constitution of a special committee to review the internet restrictions.

The bench had noted the decision on the services should have been put in the public domain.According to the affidavit, the special committee had held two meetings, before arriving at the conclusion to not ease restrictions on internet services in Jammu and Kashmir.

The affidavit added that a separate government notification was not required since the committee was formed following court's directive.

On May 15, the first meeting was held, four days after the Apex court ruling to form a panel to review internet restrictions.

In this meeting, suggestions put forward by the petitioners were discussed and also the prevailing security situation along with the impact of internet restrictions in the region were looked into.

No conclusion was reached during the meeting and it was decide to gather more inputs in connection with present situation on the ground.The committee met again on June 10 to analyse the fresh inputs.

"A thorough and comprehensive and consideration of all facets of the matter, including the feasibility of alternatives suggested by the petitioners as well as the recent occurrence of terrorism-related incidents in the region, was carried out" said tha affidavit.

A report to this effect was duly submitted by special committee to the government of Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir. This report comprises of details of the entire excercise carried out by the special committee, as well as considerations which weighted with its members. This report was also placed before the top court.

"A reading of this report would establish beyond doubt that there is no merit whatsoever in the allegations levelled against the respondents in the contempt petition", added the affidavit.

The Top court on May 11, had the directed the government to constitute a three-member high-powered committee to examine the issue involved in restoring 4G internet services in J&K.

This committee was headed by MHA Secretary, and also constituted the secretary of the Department of Telecom (DoT) and chief secretary of J&K.

The committee was asked to decide on the need to continue theArestriction of mobile internet speed to only 2G bandwidth in the region.The MHA said the Apex court order was complied "faithfully" by officials concerned of the Centre and J&K governments.

The affidavit said that the contentions regarding the alleged failure to constitute this special committee through a notification or order of the government are wholly wrong and misconceived.